[22 Paradise Rd., Northampton, Mass.]
I am not well served with ships this week – there is nothing better than the Empress, via Montreal, so this letter may reach you no sooner than my next. I'Development of Shakespeare's Verse, The'composition and revision;a3 have finished my lectures, and have only a few corrections to make; and a full programme has been arranged for me in Edinburgh, and after that is over I shall feel that I have done my duty, for some time to come, by the minor races in the Empire. And my visit will probably bring me a load of manuscripts from aspiring poets. ThenFamily Reunion, TheTSE on writing;b4 I shall really start to work on my play, and to tell the truth, I am sincerely dreading the moment, because, after such a long interruption, the plunge is fearful, and one is terrified of proving that one has undertaken something beyond one’s powers. But after the first week of pacing up and down every morning for three hours and producing nothing, I shall get used to it again, and there does seem just a chance of doing what I should like to do. MeanwhileCriterion, TheJanuary 1938;d5'Commentary' on Nuffield endowments;a1 INational Theatre, Theand TSE's January 1938 'Commentary';a2 am busy with a Commentary, to turn in for the December issue before I leave for the North: firstOxford Universityand the Nuffield endowments;a9 on the future of Oxford, with the Nuffield endowments, and second on the National Theatre 1 – a cognate subject really, as they both arise from gifts of money by rich and well-meaning men. And I look forward with exquisite pleasure to a week-end in town with nobody to see: tomorrow morning writing, a sleep at the club after lunch, work between tea and dinner, and early bed. MondayAll Souls Club, Thediscusses the Edinburgh Conference;a8 night was the All Souls Club,2 as guests of the Dean of Chichester, discussing the Edinburgh Conference, TuesdayOld Vic, TheGuthrie's Measure for Measure;b1 ‘MeasureBelgion, Montgomeryto Measure for Measure;b9 forWilliams, Charlesat Guthrie's Measure for Measure;a3 Measure’ with Belgion and Charles Williams – a very bad production, we thought, chiefly bad as producing (Tyrone Guthrie’s)3 but also in speech – one could hardly hear the poetry at all, andShakespeare, WilliamMeasure for Measure;c1 the play was played entirely on its plot, and it’s not a very good plot, or only good half way through (but I think it takes a great dramatist to get away with such poor plots as Shakespeare could); andHayward, John;h2 on Wednesday dined with John Hayward – theHutchinsons, the;b5 Hutchinsons came in before dinner, alsoBarclay, Sir Colville;a1 a young friend of John’s named Sir Colville Barclay (of Barclay’s Lager Beer)4 whoVansittart, Lady Sarita Enriqueta (née Ward)friend of JDH's;a1 is in the diplomatic service and is a son of John’s friend Lady Vansittart.5 Last night to bed early, and up early this morning for the first time since Sunday.
ItHale, Emilyreligious beliefs and practices;x1source of worry to EH;b1 is of course right that we should face our shortcomings and study them – but this has its own dangers – we can easily become too engrossed in them, and if we think them very peculiar and unusual we are wrong. You have said often enough that you think your life has been very self-centred, and egotistical – and I think often enough to do for a long time to come! You know that I think you tend too much to brood upon your own faults, which are only such as you share with most other people. And remember that I (for instance) don’t feel any more advanced than you do; and that all real help is in God, and in ourselves when seen in relation to God, and some little bit in those [?who] can help us towards God; and that when we feel ill and failing, to concentrate our attention upon our weaknesses and failings is sometimes the worst thing; and that the one ‘fundamental trouble’ is separation from God,6 and we were made for action, love and meditation, and not for brooding upon our faults.
I never have enough of your news, and of your thoughts and feelings. I am trying to learn, this year, to dash off short letters frequently, rather than wait until I can write a really good letter – which so often is only just after a good boat has gone!
1.‘A Commentary’, Criterion 17 (Jan. 1938), 254–9.
2.See S. C. Carpenter, DD, Duncan-Jones of Chichester (1956), 73, on ‘a small dining and discussion group calling itself the “All Souls’ Club,” which was founded some 25 years ago by Prebendary Mackay and Sir Henry Lunn. It consisted of six “Anglicans” and six “Nonconformists,” and its basic purpose was to investigate the possibilities of reunion between non-Roman Christians in this country. It has continued to meet ever since, but has largely widened the range of its discussions, and its numbers have been increased to seven on each side.’ Members included TSE, the Revd Dr B. Gregory, Lord Wolmer, C. T. Le Quesne, H. B. Vaisey, Norman Carter, the Revd E. C. Rich, Sir Henry Lunn, the Revd Dr Alexander.
3.Tyrone Guthrie’s production of Measure for Measure, with Emlyn Williams as Angelo, opened at the Old Vic on 12 Oct.
4.SirBarclay, Sir Colville Colville Barclay (1913–2010), diplomat, naval officer (WW2), artist and botanist.
5.LadyVansittart, Lady Sarita Enriqueta (née Ward) Vansittart (1891–1985) – born Sarita Enriqueta Ward – wife of the diplomat Sir Robert Vansittart (1881–1957), Permanent Under-Secretary at the Foreign Office, 1930–8; later Chief Diplomatic Adviser to the British government – was the widow of Sir Colville Barclay (1869–1929).
6.St Thomas Aquinas specifies this punishment for the devils: ‘Again, they are deprived of the bliss which their very nature desires’ (Summa Theologiae, vol. 9: Angels (1a, 3) (1968), 294). Boethius reckoned, in De consolatio philosophiae, ‘in omni adversitate fortunae infelicissimum est genus infortunii fuisse felicem’ (The Consolation of Philosophy [II. iv. 40], trans. H. F. Stewart and E. K. Rand (Cambridge, Mass., 1936); and Dante, ‘Nessun maggior dolore, / Che ricordarsi del tempo felice / Nella miseria’ (Inferno V. 121–3). Mephistopholes’ terrible declaration, ‘Think’st thou that I, who saw the face of God / And tasted the eternal joys of heaven, / Am not tormented with ten thousand hells / In being deprived of everlasting bliss?’ (Marlow, Dr Faustus, I.iii.79–82), makes use in turn of a quotation from St John Chrysostom (347–407): ‘if one were to speak of ten thousand hells, they would be nothing compared with being excluded from the blessed vision of heaven’ (Homily in St. Matt. xxiii.9; see John Searle, TLS, 15 Feb. 1936, 139). Milton, in Paradise Regained, stipulates this especial degree of deprivation: ‘the happy place / Imparts to thee no happiness, no joy, / Rather inflames thy torment, representing / Lost bliss, to thee no more communicable, / So never more in hell than when in heaven’ (I. 416–20); so too in Paradise Lost: ‘now the thought / Both of lost happiness and lasting pain / Torments him’ (I. 54–6).
James Joyce ‘sermonized’ in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man (1916):
Saint Thomas, the greatest doctor of the church, the angelic doctor, as he is called, says that the worst damnation consists in this, that the understanding of man is totally deprived of divine light and his affection obstinately turned away from the goodness of God … This, then, to be separated for ever from its greatest good, from God, and to feel the anguish of that separation, knowing full well that it is unchangeable: this is the greatest torment which the created soul is capable of hearing, poena damni, the pain of loss.
William Empson, in ‘This Last Pain’ (1929), 1–2:
This last pain for the damned the Fathers found:
They knew the bliss with which they were not crowned.—(Complete Poems, 52).
4.SirBarclay, Sir Colville Colville Barclay (1913–2010), diplomat, naval officer (WW2), artist and botanist.
4.MontgomeryBelgion, Montgomery (‘Monty’) Belgion (1892–1973), author and journalist: see Biographical Register.
11.JohnHayward, John Davy Hayward (1905–65), editor and critic: see Biographical Register.
5.LadyVansittart, Lady Sarita Enriqueta (née Ward) Vansittart (1891–1985) – born Sarita Enriqueta Ward – wife of the diplomat Sir Robert Vansittart (1881–1957), Permanent Under-Secretary at the Foreign Office, 1930–8; later Chief Diplomatic Adviser to the British government – was the widow of Sir Colville Barclay (1869–1929).
5.CharlesWilliams, Charles Williams (1886–1945), novelist, poet, playwright, writer on religion and theology; biographer; member of the Inklings: see Biographical Register.