In Kim Moore’s The House of Broken Things to be a mother is to risk personal peril to rescue your daughter and to be a daughter is to brave a world haunted by the ghosts of women
Be among the first to receive updates on the latest T. S. Eliot Prize news by subscribing now!
In Kim Moore’s The House of Broken Things to be a mother is to risk personal peril to rescue your daughter and to be a daughter is to brave a world haunted by the ghosts of women
The House of Broken Things rips off our rose-tinted spectacles and shows us the female body in its hairy splendour. Somehow, through Kim Moore’s warts and all vision of motherhood, love shines all the brighter.
One of the collection’s epigraphs, ‘You never saw such a wild thing as my mother’, references ‘The Bloody Chamber’, Angela Carter’s Sadeian reworking of ‘Bluebeard’. The daughter, trapped in the Marquis’s chateau, unlocks a secret room deep within it and discovers a chamber decorated with broken things – the mutilated remains of his murdered wives. Female intuition brings the mother roaring into view to save the day. To be a mother is to drive to a lonely chateau, willing to face personal peril to rescue your daughter. To be a daughter is to brave a world haunted by the ghosts of women.
Stories like ‘Bluebeard’ are a cultural permafrost: their malignity infects the everyday. It should be simple for a child to play in a park but, in ‘Taking Our Daughter to the Park’, the speaker’s partner ‘opened the gate / and the pram sailed through like a boat / into the world’. Even in her pram, even pushed by her father, the gothic intrudes; this journey of innocence into the unknown conjures Little Red Riding Hood’s walk through the forest, or entry into the Marquis’s bloody chamber. Moore’s speaker admits that ‘Now I keep imagining something / happening, something very bad’. That ‘something’ is seen twice – an automatic negative thought – at once both an improbable fiction and the aggregate of every news story seen in a lifetime. It flexes with the hidden horror of Spielberg’s shark.
‘The Black Notices’ also functions like automatic negative thoughts: ‘There’s a girl in the parking lot. No sign of any clothes. / Hungry when she died. May have been thirteen.’ Line after line of this poem is fractured, severed across its caesuras – disjunctures describing more broken things. Later in the collection, these thoughts intrude again in ‘My Black Notice’ where the body ‘found inside a pit / hole / river / // next to a motorway / border / parking lot’ belongs to the speaker and offers an insight into a woman’s thoughts on any journey – am I safe here?
‘The Kidnap’ looks again at Carter’s heroine, the mother. This time, she is aligned with the mythical figure of Demeter, willing to tackle the underworld in order to rescue her daughter, Persephone. The stage is set as we read that ‘My oldest sister went missing when I was seven, / rumoured to be “staying in a squat with some boys”.’ The sinister possibilities being easy to imagine, the mother, in response, again becomes Carter’s heroic wild mother, ‘fierce-eyed and leaping from the car’. The parents’ intervention is a disaster for all concerned:
Kidnapping in broad daylight – though now
they both deny that’s what it was. I can see my mother
can’t believe they did it, though now I understand
what you might do to get a daughter back
But Persephone has swallowed Hades’ pomegranate seeds, and ‘they would never get her back’. Yes, mothers are heroic but their love for their daughters can also be self-sabotaging and unwelcome.
One of the collection’s final poems, ‘My Mother’s Tumour’, makes a devastating comparison between child and tumour. With a black humour, Moore describes the tumour as a ‘brave, bright traveller’, evoking Fiona Benson’s exacting look at miscarriage, ‘Visitations’ (Bright Travellers, Cape Poetry, 2015). Moore’s bright traveller is a grotesque parody of pregnancy: ‘My mother / is a refuge for this tumour. / When she eats, the tumour eats.’
If that mother ‘waits and waits and waits’ as the tumour grows and the gears of the NHS grind, then ‘The Years’ is a breathless slab of a prose poem, presenting time hurtling past young mothers:
One year ago today I was breastfeeding probably with mastitis probably exhausted probably on antibiotics and she was six months old and not yet crawling and two years ago today I was twelve weeks pregnant and sick and sick all day and didn’t move from the sofa and cried alone for hours
And yet, at the end of it, there is ‘love which colours everything’.
The House of Broken Things offers us a candid, raw glimpse of motherhood – and of the lives lived by girls and women – and its existence makes the world a better place.
Kim Moore’s The House of Broken Things (Corsair Poetry) is shortlisted for the T. S. Eliot Prize 2026. John Field blogs at Poor Rude Lines.
Be among the first to receive updates on the latest T. S. Eliot Prize news by subscribing now!
Be among the first to receive updates on the latest T. S. Eliot Prize news by subscribing now!